The top one looks the best because it does look deviated towards the Magisteriums "Feel." Also the 1st option in identity does look a look more professional and "Scholarlike" than the other two, but thats just my opinion!
The only criticism I would possibly say out of the choice you put there Dead is possibly do a darker green perhaps? It looks a bit lightish.
Edit: Also going to comment that the first option had about 70% + Votes too!
_________________
Xalibossk, Body Tamer & Terror Of The Underdark
Khuul-Khuum -Icy Heart Award 2014- Joint 2nd Best Developed 2014!Ordained Of Her Grace