Joined: 29 Aug 2006 Location: Victoria, BC, Canada
The Amia ideal of "smart evil" (A term I hate) far too often ends up with the evil characters not actually doing anything even remotely evil the vast majority of the time which rather defeats the purpose of being evil in the first place, since it adds a little more evil balance with 10x as much of the same. And "dumb good" as just as much an issue with the lack of evil since far too often the "good guys" have some hair triggers for evil that should probably get them some evil points of their own.
Tarkuul is Tarkuul, and the only people who generally ever actually seem to care about Tarkuul are the people that are a part of it. Openly Tarkuul has time and again just stood and basically exclaimed "We just want to be left alone" and have kept out other evil types who might bring danger to it. So yeah sure, Tarkuul is evil, but its generally a rather self contained ball of evil that looks out for a very specific set of goals and type of evil.
And frankly part of the issue is simply this attitude that Players should come in and build up Evil and then make it more open since that "building" phase often takes AGES on Amia with often little or Anything happening for weeks or months. Change is painfully slow at times and the "building" RP (especially in literal cases of things like faction areas) has been used and reused as a plot device to occupy players so often that it hardly inspires. And so the Amia options for evil often end up Being 1) go out in a blaze or 2) bleed dry as you wait.
Because there isn't enough of an evil safety net to allow any middle ground in most cases.
I haven't seen you since we talked about how to handle hungry undead. But our timezones are different.
For me, it feels as if our biggest critics have not made the effort to see what we are up to.
I know exactly what Tarkuul is up to, OOCly, and honestly, I don't think it draws any conclusion other than "a tree falling in the woods, someone might not even see it." Regardless of how evil some of you guys think that plot is, it's really not going to turn anyone's heads likely no matter how far along it gets.
You know nothing Jon Snow
_________________
Life should be prolonged only when it serves the greater cause of the death of the world.
Joined: 15 Dec 2009 Location: The Sky Above The Rain.
No matter for how long you go awol, anytime you check the forum a thread such as this is up and running.
I wonder how long it'll take for people to understand that for this there is no solution. Good will always complain about overpower of evil (like during Banite raids), evil will always complain about pwnz0r goodly paladins (like ... well, just like now ).
The funniest part is that one cannot exist without the other. It's like a teen couple that hate each other, but give them a seperated weekend and they'll eat each other's face on Monday.
By the way, I do remember how Kohlingen grew up. I was a part of it, be it during the building of Kohlingen from nothing but a wooden outpost raided twice a day by Banite raiding party to a place it is now. The argument is completely wrong and kinda offensive to those players who invested years in building that place (not me, mind you. I mean players who literally breath for the place).
That said, just the argument regarding Kohlingen is wrong. Some other points FW made are actually spot on, but as i said - with no obvious solution.
_________________ Mercadier - *sleeps six feet under the warm sands of Khem* Alex - Life is adventure or nothing! Eddie - Sex, drugs and rock'n... more sex. ========= Obsidian (inactive)
I haven't seen you since we talked about how to handle hungry undead. But our timezones are different.
For me, it feels as if our biggest critics have not made the effort to see what we are up to.
I know exactly what Tarkuul is up to, OOCly, and honestly, I don't think it draws any conclusion other than "a tree falling in the woods, someone might not even see it." Regardless of how evil some of you guys think that plot is, it's really not going to turn anyone's heads likely no matter how far along it gets.
You know nothing Jon Snow
Nailed it. It's not even a joke. You literally cannot even start guessing. And it's not going to turn anyone's head because it's in our interest not to turn anyone's head.
Joined: 14 Dec 2004 Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada
Just putting this out there but Evil does not require someone to engage in mass homicide.
Hell, my Banite *YEs I played one* , barely engaged in PvP conflict but was Evil to the core. She was unlike some, an Evil that felt itself nescessary for the greater stability and survivability of the Realms..
Sadly, she fell into some politics and also ended up going on a three hour tour that went horribly awry , but I still had fun playing her, Did I need to kill anyone? Maybe a Sacrifice in the Black Hand's name but that's different.
And, Kohlingen and Cordor, while strong are far from invincble.
Originally I wasn't going to share my piece, but as I see that the DMs thus far haven't left a piece of their minds here, I guess I'll do it, but more as a personal opinion and not reflective of the team as a whole.
A month or two ago I tried my hand at DMing for a small evil faction. By the time I came in, they were already planning to quit. I offered to take them up in an attempt to revitalize their idea and give them goals, quests to maintain outside of their time with player vs. player interaction. It was going very well...for maybe a week. After that, everything exploded into chaos pretty much. They were the type that was exploring blatant evil. They didn't want to do another sleuthy, quiet, slow corruption evil. They wanted something different, and I truly did respect that. I am not at all adverse against evil. In fact I play a lot of evil characters, I've been through dozens of small fledgling groups and through a lot less of bigger criminal organizations on Amia. I really enjoy that facet of things.
But, what really put them off was the abuse coming to them OOCly and well as their DM, me. I got so many complaints in that one small period of DMing for them, accusations of favoritism, bias, rule breaking, etc. Every little thing I did, a few certain people were watching me. It seemed almost as if they were waiting for a reason to play us up. Simultaneously, the group was being ignored ICly, sent messages via Skype about how certain people wanted no further interaction time and time again, getting accusations flung at their person for purely IC events. This was perfectly off-putting for all parties involved. I nearly took a break from Amia for this exact reason. And this is unfortunately what happens, time and time again, to us DMs who support and have supported evil in the past (and present). I hope you can see how we would be further hesitant to lend a hand unless we know the benefits will outweigh the costs for gaining so much attention and flack.
At least, that's my side of the story. I would love to DM for an evil faction and help them grow, but the last time I tried, it took so much out of me that I would have to ponder really hard on whether or not it would be worth it this time around.
Let me start this post by saying this in NO WAY an attack or an attempt to flame. It is simply my experience with the group you are referring to.
The majority of the players in this group were great guys and fun to rp with. I have this to several DMs in fact. The problem was that there two in that group who, instead of attempting to rp a situation would almost always resort to pvp. Additionally. anytime a person obtained information about their group and I will use myself as an example, we were almost immediately contacted by a DM and asked for proof of where we obtained the information, nevermind the fact they were often discussing things in public where anyone good in stealth could overhear or, in some cases, anyone just walking by could hear. One person, after an ambush failed that they arranged for my character with the same second person that was a problem, logged within minutes of dying (we're talking three or four tops) while rp was still going on. Not a word was said to the rest of us, leaving us hanging. The other player ran off a few feet then logged and came back on under a new character, leaving those chasing him unable to continue to do so. Later our group was told the player who's pc had died had logged for bed....but he had come back on a short time later under a new pc.
I could go on about things that two players had done, such as walking into an area under one pc, seeing a specific character there and flipping to another pc, coming back killing that character then immediately logging back to the original pc. Yes, this stuff was reported to and it made quite a few of us decide that, while we would enjoy rping with the rest of the group, due to those specific two player we did not wish to deal with the group as a whole. Some of us were given ooc grief for that as well, such as being contacted by other players on why we weren't rping, asking us to rp or in one case even accusing me of blocking all of that group's rp. It wasn't true and it wasn't fair. I was even told by one of those two players, when I stated my desire to not be involved in their rp further, that I did not have the right to do so and that I needed to "get the fuck over it". That is a quote. Had the server not crashed, I would have sent in that screenshot. On Skype, I had most of their group as contacts. One of them, the same one who predominately screamed about "meta" being used against their group, would try and tell me things about them, then grow angry when I would tell him not to as that could lead to more metagame claims and I was no metagamer. On a previous server I played on before I took a five year break from the game, I watched over six rl months of daily (and I'm talking all day long) RP be destroyed and a friend's character of over two years become unplayable because someone metagamed information in a group team speak type call (one of the reasons I won't join them anymore in fact, nothing personal).
Do I have a problem rping evil or with evil? No. Those who know my tiefling can verfiy she's done some really not nice things, such as abducting a baby and a few small animals and giving to a Sharran to conduct some experimental spells on in exchange for armor. She's betrayed and been betrayed and it's all been fun. I think the entire problem when it comes to "evil', and again this is my opinion only breaks down to the following:
Some people do not like to take the consequences for their actions
Some people forget the person on the other side of the monitor is not their character
Too many decide that evil is doing a powerbuild and relying on PVP as the predominant form of their evil action, rather than more RP.
Good characters can and do engage in evil actions and without consequences, yes. They should pay the price for what they've done. Evil should too.
Again, this is only MY opinion and MY experience, and NOT an attack or anything to start a flame war. Evil CAN work on Amia, and I've seen numerous groups on here pull it off and beautifully so. Several of my characters have been involved either by being evil or being the ones set up. I loved it.
_________________
Last edited by CrazyCatLady on Thu, Nov 05 2015, 22:28 PM, edited 1 time in total.
And, Kohlingen and Cordor, while strong are far from invincble.
Yeah the trick is to soften them up first trying to attack something when its at full power with a zerg rush is silly, Cordor is much weaker then what it was because of the in fighting with the west and the effects of the war.
_________________ ================-<Cory ShadowFlame>-================ Risenlord-Shifter(OMG a Non-Dragon Shifter that can hold his own in PvE)
Joined: 20 Apr 2008 Location: The downeaster "Alexa"
Quote:
Hell, my Banite *YEs I played one* , barely engaged in PvP conflict but was Evil to the core. She was unlike some, an Evil that felt itself nescessary for the greater stability and survivability of the Realms..
That reminds me. Another thing that seems to lead Evil groups to their downfall is they feel the onus of conflict falls to them. When people tell me they like playing evil characters, usually what they say is something to the effect of liking to "stir the pot," spark tension, or shake things up. These things are fine, but again, aren't necessarily more a part of Evil than they are Good, Chaos, and in some cases even Law(bringing law to a lawless land, for instance, creates conflict). So some of the time it isn't so much a matter of Evil not having backing, but, again, a matter of status quo. And thinking your only job as an Evil PC is to cause conflict often results in feeling like the odds are against you, because the system is always fighting to get back to that equilibrium. And equilibrium that is, as I said, nestled in Neutral/Good just based off of how the settlements are.
I'm interested to see how an "Evil" settlement would look like, as described by a player who feels like there is the distinct lack of one. If someone would like to theorize one, how it comes about without getting curbstomped in its first week, how it maintains relationships on an isle and such once it's built up, I think we'd get some good insight into why it hasn't happened yet. Heck, even if you can't describe how it'd be built, describe how it functions as your brand of Evil and remains in tact. A huge evil castle falls from the sky with Lv 40 NPC guards, plot armor buildings, and DM backing. Where does it go from there?
_________________
You think Magic is your ally... but you merely adopted the Art. He was born in it. Molded by it. Sometimes, an angel is simply a devil with better intentions.
And, Kohlingen and Cordor, while strong are far from invincble.
Yeah the trick is to soften them up first trying to attack something when its at full power with a zerg rush is silly, Cordor is much weaker then what it was because of the in fighting with the west and the effects of the war.
That's simply fiction. I've heard players and DM's make fun of other players' attempts to do anything to Kohlingen, claiming that its "laughable that a group of 11 PC's wanted to do anything to 5000 armed kohlingen knights".
As someone who's killed over 25 NPC's in kohlingen. Yes, something can be done. But at the end of the day, it's nothing significant. Just a new story to get upset about for 15 minutes the next time you RP. When we lose, we actually have the ground we're standing on ripped out from under us and have nothing at all, lol. Before you go "Why are you destroying" lets just say I took a suggestion that someone gave me the last time this thread came around. They said "Any time you get attacked for no reason and win anyways, kill someone innocent in Kohlingen". Well, that's what happened. The only thing that actually resulted from that was raging OOC on their end, and tons of civilian deaths until I deemed it not even worth logging in on that PC anymore.
We've tried so many things with Kohlingen, and realisticly, it's just impossible to do anything. Keep in mind the area spans a daunting 33 zones, and it's incredulous to even think you can do anything with those odds, given the DM lack of willingness to even help do something as simple as poison the water supply. (Yes, did that. Wanna know how they beat it? They drank potions LOL)
Wanna know a secret? The area is so big it actually is the reason a half dozen evil hangouts were removed from the game. Some of these areas were even added sans any RP by a developer 'just cause'.
Hell, we even had someone be a butcher and give people poisoned meat. The DM's completely ignored that, too.
And please.. really? Cordor? It's like less than a year since a MAJOR CATACLYSM, and it's MORE BEAUTIFUL than it ever was? Give me a break.
Quote:
A huge evil castle falls from the sky with Lv 40 NPC guards, plot armor buildings, and DM backing. Where does it go from there?
Wherever the plot takes it, which can involve players, DM's and other people? Just like any other place??
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
Last edited by RaveN on Thu, Nov 05 2015, 21:21 PM, edited 5 times in total.
Joined: 14 Dec 2004 Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada
Giving poisoned meat being ignored? That's curious.. I wonder who actually ran that one since that is better as long as you can get it through and not have it caught before a bunch of people eat it.
We had a several month mission for one of our PC's to build a reputation as a butcher PC in Kohlingen. Ultimately the DM's ignored it, and the players metagamed the name tag.
I remember that. It was an interesting plan, but I can't say one way or another on the meta. He was kinda obvious about it >_> He was really, really creepy IC, lol. MY Kohl PC didn't trust him entirely because of that. Unfortunately if there was meta, I only had what was reported to go off on D:
_________________ Whomst've'll'd'mn't I play: Salema Nefahri::A penny for your thots Zrae'a'stra'fryn::That which nightmares are made of Khasir::From the East a storm is coming
Joined: 15 Dec 2009 Location: The Sky Above The Rain.
Ahahaha... the butcher. Or the "sausage" man, right? Yes, he was not creepy at all. Like that nice man who's handing over candy to kids on the playground, with the windowless van parked just nearby.
Very subtle. No one could ever find out IC he was in fact a creep. No, siree, it must have been meta.
C'mon, Fade.
_________________ Mercadier - *sleeps six feet under the warm sands of Khem* Alex - Life is adventure or nothing! Eddie - Sex, drugs and rock'n... more sex. ========= Obsidian (inactive)
This thread isn't about was never meant to be about any specific events. There are at least dozen more, namely the Imperator (which is only recently gone, who literally was a god protecting Kohlingen), etc,etc. We've tried basically everything, it all failed equally and the DM's wouldn't do any of the other ideas that might've worked. They still won't, and I'm not even going to bother trying to change that. Kohlingen is invincible. Until proven otherwise, by being removed from the map, the same way all of evil bases are, that is simply just how it is. while($i=1 == 1);
At the end of the day, after being told that if I tried something in Kohlingen, I'd be permadeathed, and then when I watch how the last 5 bases of mine blowed up, where most of the people in the assault died and came back 2-3 times during the same fight, I just laugh. You can argue and be politically correct, but lol, this is broken, has been for a long time, and if you don't see it, I don't even know what to say.
This thread is about evil (not me) building an indestructible base (up to the storywriters) with a plot that is DM driven. Where you all seem to get tripped up is that you expect a faction to want to do it for the n'th time, when you've clearly been informed why they've all given up.
From paid entities, yes. Not always though. The paid entities in question were level 1 NPC's anyone could've killed though. Stark contrast to a tiny place like Guldurand, who suddenly has spike walls as tall as my ingame camera, and invincible guards from the get-go, hmm?
For the Banite Keep, for example, myself and others farmed clay literally for weeks. Just sitting there, and getting clay. It was absurd. On top of that, I personally put in 30,000,000 gold into, as well as countless other raw materials.
Funnily enough, Imperator's dead, so he's not immortal, just like Kohlingen. Gather enough people, Kohlingen will fall. I'm sure Rigela will tell you the same.
Tarkuul has a vastly better defense than the others. Evil cities have time and time again been destroyed because, well, they're evil, and if you made them an invincible city, it would be so boring to play from there, that there simply wouldn't be a point in joining, because there wouldn't be a threat. That's just like saying that London is an immortal city because it's not fallen. Bomb it, it'll fall.
If you really think that your previous bases were good enough to be held on par with Kohlingen, or Cordor, I'm sorry to say but you're mistaken. The evidence is plain as day, in the obvious situation that they are here, those are not.
Yes, you would be perma'd if you failed an attempt to destroy a city, it's a massive plot hook.
I also point out again, that several players can back me on, that the Celestial Stairway were put into confinement of the Holy City, and they managed to break out, and kill a good 20-30 guards on their way out. Another point proving the mortality of the Holy City.
If you genuinely refuse to see the evidence and points provided in this thread to make your point moot, I don't think you want to be proved other wise, meaning you're arguing for the sake of arguing. Though, instead of assuming that's the case, I want to ask what you hope to achieve with this debate.
(I beg you don't take any of this to offense, I'm tired, and may come across snappy. That's not my intention by any means.)
I also say that as an extension of the Commonwealth, Guldorand was immediately under full supply, rendering them a different matter.
If you really think that your previous bases were good enough to be held on par with Kohlingen, or Cordor, I'm sorry to say but you're mistaken. The evidence is plain as day, in the obvious situation that they are here, those are not.
I don't think you're even reading the intention of any of these post, just being quick to denounce that anything is wrong, and blaming me for not thinking of the solution. There you have it, though, the players have spoken. Is it still our fault for being ghosts?
Let me spell it out in plain bold and underlined text.
I think evil needs a "CITY" (or even CASTLE) that is NOT created by a faction.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
Last edited by RaveN on Thu, Nov 05 2015, 22:23 PM, edited 1 time in total.
Joined: 14 Dec 2004 Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada
Ah, the Spike walls and such were likely the product of a major power choosing to show investment in it post Banites. (IE: Cordor).
Perhaps there was some unfair consideration from DM's in the past , but I would hazard if a well thought out and realistic plan was brought to them nowadays they might give it a go. Will it succeed? Does any plan go completely unscathed when it achieves contact with the enemy? From my experience hells no.
Kohlingen, and Cordor are both cities .. even if weakened from the war they have a lot more at their disposal. Yes, someone could go in and violently start slaughtering folk. Hell, for a while they could skirmish if they really wanted to, BUT... you get to a point where the big guns get called in if you push enough, at that point you need to decide if it's better to withdraw or proceed and risk permanent destruction.
And.. to reply: I'm pretty sure Tarkuul hadn't been created by a faction, I could be wrong and if I am, I apologize.
As I've already said, Tarkuul is not an overtly evil city. It's more neutral with its actions, unless you count the SUPER SUPER SUPER secret plot that still nobody will get to really see and care about.
It has in the past and present banned people for being evil banned people for being undead banned people for being in an evil faction has a voice NPC which foils any plan you might have because secrecy is nil and nobody wants to RP there, because the voice literally interrupts you has removed an entire church of velsharoon for holding a paladin hostage after it tried to single handedly invade the city continues to advocate not doing anything non-secretive to prospective people who get involved removed people from the council for being evil removed people from the council for favoring undead deities over the presumed development that the presiding DM wanted and now it apparently doesnt even care if all of its undead die
Tarkuul isn't the fix. Zanshibon isn't the fix. Shadowscape isn't the fix. Just.. no. Tarkuul is doing just fine all by itself, attracting the players it does. I want a place that attracts all evil, and isn't too committed to do anything, just being a meeting point and generally a place to RP.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
Last edited by RaveN on Thu, Nov 05 2015, 22:33 PM, edited 1 time in total.
I haven't once said that any of the cities were created by factions, so can you please drop the attitude?
I don't disagree with you, Faded, it would be easier for evil to be a factor if there were a base they could operate. But it being invincible, to me, sounds daft. Though I'm all for it, I don't think DMs should just put one there. I think players should build it. No, it's not easy, there is always going to be setbacks.
I'm done responding to you if you're going to talk down at me like shit, though. Get off your high horse.
Joined: 02 Jun 2015 Location: Georgia, United States.
I've waited a while before posting here. While I think Fade holds somewhat good to a argument. From what I've seen of Tarkuul it's very evil. There's nothing neutral about a City constructed of Undead, Necromanctic Individuals and others. Just because they don't openly advocate violence doesn't mean their neutral. It just means Tarkuul plays it smart. I think some reasons to why people get banned from Tarkuul is because their openly abusive and attract attention that Tarkuul doesn't want, because they want to remain under the radar so they can continue their evil plans.
Joined: 14 Dec 2004 Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada
LibrisMortis_666 wrote:
I've waited a while before posting here. While I think Fade holds somewhat good to a argument. From what I've seen of Tarkuul it's very evil. There's nothing neutral about a City constructed of Undead, Necromanctic Individuals and others. Just because they don't openly advocate violence doesn't mean their neutral. It just means Tarkuul plays it smart. I think some reasons to why people get banned from Tarkuul is because their openly abusive and attract attention that Tarkuul doesn't want, because they want to remain under the radar so they can continue their evil plans.
Libris has the right of it at least from what I can see.
That Voice is likely set to ensure Tarkuul's survival through whatever means it thinks nescessary. It doesn't have the raw firepower to go on a conquering spree, so it alongside the council does what it has to, to survive.
I'm not really talking about a conquering spree. I'm talking about it's refusal to harbor people suspected of minor crimes. Keep in mind, that it has annihilators, which can literally nuke anything to the ground, from what I understand.
Regardless of what Tarkuul is or isn't, it is not what any of the evil players like myself, or any of the evil players who have left who share a similar opinion about a thematic gap in our amia setting or lastly, aspiring evil are looking for. Tarkuul is perfectly fine as it is, it's just not for us. That ship sailed when the regime of DM changed a couple years ago.
Quote:
I'm done responding to you if you're going to talk down at me like shit, though. Get off your high horse.
Sorry about that, that comment I did say earlier was belittling, but perhaps if you re-read what prompted it, you can understand my frustration.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
Last edited by RaveN on Thu, Nov 05 2015, 22:46 PM, edited 1 time in total.
Joined: 23 Sep 2012 Location: Western Australia (+8 GMT)
People who do nothing but stir shit (And not to the benefit or favour of Tarkuul) and then try to use Tarkuul as a safe-haven are going to have a bad time.
_________________ Elwyn Sabel - Laura Jarshall - Mordoc Ebonhand
Joined: 02 Jun 2015 Location: Georgia, United States.
I'm curious to hear /what/ is your type of evil? Suggestions of making a island not dedicated to a faction for "evil" players. Amia lacks the amount of players to add on to the server when apparently places are going to be removed over time, Like Khem.
So let's say a island is created for "evil" players, with no faction it being based off of. Surely a faction will up-rise that takes a pretty powerful adjustment towards said location. Like how the Gentlemen's Club literally grabbed it's Government by the balls and made them superior power, and Cordor isn't a Evil location. So instead of adding onto the server, perhaps find a way to force a faction with people who share the same similarities in evil-character's with you, and force your way into a civilization.
[quote="Faded Wings"]I'm not really talking about a conquering spree. I'm talking about it's refusal to harbor people suspected of minor crimes. Keep in mind, that it has annihilators, which can literally nuke anything to the ground, from what I understand.[quote]
Also, why would Tarkuul shelter individuals that break even the slightest crime if it brings someone unwanted knocking at their doorstep? That doesn't make much sense.
I still don't get your point. What is wrong with Amia B?
Just let me give you a scenario: Let's say that your evil person befriends with Paush. She then gathers a group around her and begins to kill/explode/raid/eat on Amia A then in the end returns to Amia B. The good guys cannot follow them because they have Paush's protection who as a ruler of a layer can block any incoming gate to his realm.
So let's say a island is created for "evil" players, with no faction it being based off of. Surely a faction will up-rise that takes a pretty powerful adjustment towards said location. Like how the Gentlemen's Club literally grabbed it's Government by the balls and made them superior power, and Cordor isn't a Evil location. So instead of adding onto the server, perhaps find a way to force a faction with people who share the same similarities in evil-character's with you, and force your way into a civilization.
Err.. what about the characters who are not well adjusted.. like viewtopic.php?f=58&t=84093 this post, for example. My PC is not excited to go into Cordor (even West), to be frank, because it's mostly a unnecessary serious risk. While I don't think your idea is bad, I will just say that we tried to do that to several other places, and it actually ended up with them building high walls and invincible NPC's plastered all over.
Quote:
I still don't get your point. What is wrong with Amia B?
Nothing is wrong with Amia B, except that it's not on Amia.
Joined: 02 Jun 2015 Location: Georgia, United States.
What do you mean by "well adjusted"
[quote][/Err.. what about the characters who are not well adjusted.. like viewtopic.php?f=58&t=84093 this post, for example. My PC is not excited to go into Cordor (even West), to be frank, because it's mostly a unnecessary serious risk. While I don't think your idea is bad, I will just say that we tried to do that to several other places, and it actually ended up with them building high walls and invincible NPC's plastered all over. [quote]
The loose definition I'm using for this: a non-well adjusted person is a PC character who is banned from places like Cordor (not west, neccessarily) Kohlingen, overtly evil (or was evil in the past), has a reputation for such.
I still don't get your point. What is wrong with Amia B?
Faded Wings wrote:
Nothing is wrong with Amia B, except that it's not on Amia.
Well..Amia is a small island and evil have to play smart there as they did most of the times. If you don't like Tarkuul then that is your personal problem.
But even when Wyrmhold still stood they banned the newly forming Horsemen of Apocalypse, because they raised the attention of the Defenders. Wyrmhold was evil and they harbored evil as long as they didn't raise too much attention. Why? Because Wyrmhold had other plans due to the Wyrmshadow prophecy and 6 months later they attacked Kohlingen.
Maybe Tarkuul has something else in mind why they do not want to get your attention? If you want to hang out there but in the meantime you want to kill someone then make some effort to cover things up? I know of several PCs who did that and they haven't been noticed at all. If they were able to do it then others can do as well.
Furthermore, if you want to play a CE then the said CE character is likely a mental case. Insane people generally do not get along with other people, especially if they are evil psycho or sociopaths. Your CE character who kills everyone will likely end up as a mercenary of an employer who has patience or who can lock him up and release him when needed, or sooner or later he will become an outcast of the society and will end up in a tower of his own where he kills everyone who comes nearby.
Joined: 02 Jun 2015 Location: Georgia, United States.
I honestly don't believe this topic is of much use now. Seems like the same thing is set on replay.
My advice:
1.) Try to gather as many people with the same common interest as you, and work from there.
2) Contact DMs about said projects. You can easily repair a destroyed ruin and make it a real city, it just takes time and patience.
3) Best way to survive on Amia as a "evil" character- DON'T be stupid and do ridiculously violent things and expect no reaction. As stated numerous times being secret, hiding your evidence e.t.c can keep you secure.
The problem with that line of thought however is that it results in the same recurring problems.
1) Large organised groups acting in a conflict-driven evil fashion almost always attract the attention of everyone who wants to stick a blade in them. While resulting in decent in game conflict, the OOC conflict is very rarely pleasant for anyone involved.
2) They can build all the cities they want, but unless those cities are given enough plot armor they will be crushed in an hour or two with impunity.
3) You can hide your evil well enough but it turns into the Tarkuul problem of 'congratulations, your evil plan has been successful, but nobody noticed so this RP will only serve to make people roll their eyes when you tell them what you did which has no effect on them whatsoever'.
_________________ Player of: Asya Goodmonsdottir - Knight of Lesser Gods. -Winner of 2014's "Razored Tongue" Award, and Emcee's pick "Authoritarian of the year". Jannah Vindle - Mistress of Coin.
All these comments about Tarkuul... its now been made a challenge to blow it up.
Ask Asya, she will sell you the secret of blowing up Tarkuul with an empty shot glass for approximately one hundred million gold coins.
But trying to not be snippy (I apologise for my last post, which seems that way on rereading it...) and more constructive.
The problem with open evil as a function is more or less that you need to engineer a situation in which there are negative consequences for opposing them beyond immediate death for the good guys (who all carry raise dead scrolls). I feel that what's missing as a factor is that these sorts of groups need to find themselves a way to be put into a position in which they are necessary. The closest to a successful open evil faction in recent history (The drug dealing, well poisoning, pale master inclusive Gentlemen's club) only achieved this by having it so that open opposition to them on an official level would result in a civil war in Cordor.
I find that the problem is that there's nothing in the game which can be relied upon to cause this situation without a DM handing it to someone. Normally a group of evil folks could cause all sorts of problems indirectly to a massive settlement, but in our server there's nothing all these settlements depend upon. Resources are almost functionally infinite, there's not much indication of external trade, and all settlements are already self sufficient whether canonically or by merit of DM's not keeping much track of what any group needs to survive.
Evil as a group only really has two readily apparent options to cause havoc for whatever reason they want, and those are to either dig in and create a fortress at great expense which will likely be stomped out, or work to destroy a settlement which they will inevitably fail at as they will never gain sufficient background support to match the 'the place you're attacking has 50,000 knights' issue.
There's not 5000 evil knights around, or many groups which are readily about to produce them within this generation. Most attempts at gaining support of background NPC groups result in the problem of 'these monsters are too dumb and want to go back to being mobs for grinding' And if every faction has nothing to do but sit around reaping the benefits of already becoming untouchable, the bad guys don't get any purchase in an area where they could see fit to make events fall into place where people have no option but to suck it up and deal with the fact that they exist.
_________________ Player of: Asya Goodmonsdottir - Knight of Lesser Gods. -Winner of 2014's "Razored Tongue" Award, and Emcee's pick "Authoritarian of the year". Jannah Vindle - Mistress of Coin.
I'm not going to try and offer an opinion on this one way or the other, however I gladly offer my help with organization, idea creation and developer input to any group of players out there that are interested in starting a type of evil RP that we don't currently have.
I only have one precondition to that help: I will not instantly port in a plot proof evil fort/village/city for the sake of simply having one. If you have goals to work towards that I am all there for you, I'm just not going to hand it out.
Likewise I will not be handing out any new plot proof areas to any other groups be they good, neutral or evil with out the work being put in to 'build' it.
I still don't get your point. What is wrong with Amia B?
Nothing is wrong with Amia B, except that it's not on Amia.
Ok so your unhappy that a number of large settlements with allies militia's, army's, resources...ect on a small island wont just let groups who made it clear their intentions were to "screw up all your shit and cause chaos and murder" build up a base down the street from them?
Yes B-mia is slow and gets limited players/chance for walking into RP unless you build your base on top of a epic loot dropping monster.......BUT THATS WHAT YOU WANT AS EVIL! You want to go unnoticed till its to late because you already set up your settlement with defences, trained people, I would be recruiting monsters who I'm sure are sick of getting mass murdered by the Adventurer types.
_________________ ================-<Cory ShadowFlame>-================ Risenlord-Shifter(OMG a Non-Dragon Shifter that can hold his own in PvE)
Since I was mentioned, maybe it would be helpful to explain what happened with Haan in detail, now that most characters are dead and gone. It can, I think, help to serve as an example of Evil trying to do exactly as has been suggested but still coming up short.
Before I begin, though, I'll make a quick summary of what's been asked of evil players by the community in order to be successful: 1.) Be smart evil, don't be stupid. Don't get into unnecessary fights. 2.) Gather players. 3.) Be secretive and secure. 4.) Get a DM to help with projects, build your city with patience and effort.
In his prime, Haan was responsible for a criminal network spanning across 34 different players and in possession of the deed to a fully constructed castle beneath the ground accessible only by leyline. He had relative immunity from Cordorian law. He had constructed alliances consisting of Asmodeans, Thayans, Drow, Slavers, a Tiamatian Flight, Necromancers, Tarkuul*, Loviatarrans, and general scumbags.
And with a really well-executed betrayal and assassination, it vanished in a single night!
~ ~ ~
Haan first met with Secretary Mover, devising a plan to create a scapegoat organization. Basically, Haan would glean some of the immunity and reputation that Mover enjoyed, and would appear as if wielding the reins to Cordor's criminal network in order to draw out opposition and gather intelligence. The entire building of a criminal organization was conducted on illusions that Haan was who he said he was, all for the sake of learning who could be trusted. And it worked really well.
One by one, I invited characters to a council of criminals that never previously existed; all under the pretense that they'd been selected by an organization that also never existed. And in this way, I carefully recruited no less than 15-20 people in the course of a month, or less. By the time characters would have realized that it was all built on an illusion, the sheer weight of our numbers allowed us to move a great deal of influence in the underworld-- to the point that his power was no longer illusory. In a short time, we bartered for an agreement to an old Thayan fortress and officially had our base. It was unoccupied by NPC guards, and we quickly tried to order those up-- but to no avail.
At this time, our conflict with good guys was strictly through tension roleplay, and even then it was vague. While he didn't lift a finger, Haan would throw his Mover-Afforded weight around by intimidating and paying off guards, and generally giving the impression that he was 'in charge'. (Again, as part of the counter-intelligence plan he was supposed to become a target!) We specifically didn't want to provide destructive roleplay to the server. As a faction, we just wanted to build until we were at a point where we could experience the same kind of DM legitimacy and protections as other settlements-- THEN begin being a more open source of conflict.
Our sin, really, was that we built veeery fast. I was able to organize almost all of the server's evil characters under one roof. Of course there was going to be betrayals. Of course there was going to be infighting and security leaks. But I embraced these possibilities because to me, it was worth it. I wanted to create a settlement for evil, and the only way I was going to do that with my own patience level was to invite players into my home so that they could produce RP for each other and find enough entertainment in it that in time they would want to preserve it themselves.
Before we could become a legitimate threat to the heroes of the server, we were betrayed by elements within Tarkuul. The assassination sequence and the complete seizure of the keep was amazingly performed. Still one of my all-time favorite hits. Now-- before there are complaints, I'm not at all saying that Tarkuul didn't have a reason for doing what it did. Or that individuals didn't have valid, justified reasons for wanting Haan and his group tamed. Or even that I played it entirely responsibly, myself.
But in the end, for its own reasons, evil stabbed evil in the back-- and there hasn't been as large or diverse a conglomerate of evil ever since. So looking back on the expectations of players:
1.) Be smart evil, don't be stupid. Don't get into unnecessary fights. Some may disagree, but I don't think what we were trying to accomplish was stupid, brazen evil that flew in the face of players and forced itself to be killed. We were defensive, we weren't out every day attacking players. We certainly didn't get into unnecessary fights; we were just irresponsibly large and successful. I as a player embraced RP security risks in order to get a group of players together in a way that just hadn't been done before. 2.) Gather players. This we certainly did! Perhaps too well. But at the time, my goal was just to get people involved in something. So many people were excited to finally feel like evil had something. We had fancy cigars, a "hidden" fortress. We had fancy clothes, and plotted great schemes. 3.) Be secretive and secure. We weren't overt evil, but we also weren't entirely secretive either. At the time, there wasn't a great amount of information about us floating around in good-aligned circles. For the most part, we were staying relatively secret from the good guys. But we pushed hard to recruit on the bad-guy front. As for security, we lost every amount of it by being confined to using leyline entries. When the betrayal happened, anyone could have walked through-- and people were very often brought there by friends just so they could bind. But this isn't something we just overlooked or forgot about. Countless times, we sought NPC devil guardians who could provide us some kind of legitimacy, but it was never received. 4.) Get a DM to help with projects, build your city with patience and effort. The help I had from the DM's in the initial recruitment phase was amazing. It wasn't really in the form of resources, but reputation. I would ask for a DM to help oversee a simple, well-paid bartender who, by the very nature of coming to life via DM possession, gave my lies all kinds of credibility. But if you think about it, from a principle standpoint building your city isn't nearly as easy as it's been made to sound.
If you've never experienced being on the bad side, what you may not know is that the good-aligned cities have an incredible intelligence communication network. If you slip and become recognized as an evil character, no less than four cities will in a single day have you banned and marked as an enemy. Now imagine if you're trying to build a settlement. Imagine how you would even.. try? You just can't hide that kind of growth. And in a single day, half of the island will mobilize to crush you. Unfortunately, because the building group of players was un-established, they also don't receive protection.
There, updated. I've tried Amian conflict in sooo many flavors. I've played Drow, I've played slavers, criminal masterminds, Occult priests. I've done secretive evil, I've done open evil. It's just really hard. Amia as a region just doesn't really have any more believable sources of powerful evil that could make for a good "Settlement of Sin."
That being said, however, instead of a settlement build around evil there may be room for a settlement designed around chaos instead. There was a really cool period of time where refugees from the war could have made some kind of shanty town. Chaos can be just as much a source of conflict as evil against good.
In the end, though, I just couldn't make it work-- try as I did! I felt so obliged to try to create conflict, because I was so distraught that it wasn't happening. I pushed, and pushed; but in the end, I've just moved on.
Oh this thread, again. Usual suspects defending the usual views. 6 years running, same story. Faded, love ya for trying... This is the fate Amia chose though, accept it or set sails.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum