|
|
|
Dark Immolation
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 6:53 AM |
|
|

Developer
Joined: 20 Apr 2008 Location: The downeaster "Alexa"
|
|
I don't think it's that simple. It's just that, frankly, it feels like Faded is suggesting that something so specific should exist out-of-nothing. I want a place that looks and functions like Fortuna from DMC4 or maybe Dipan from Valykrie Profile... but it can't just apparate into existence like that. Many people have given suggestions of how something like that might come to be, but everything is met with the view that it's too hard or that by going the route, you're somehow not accomplishing the end idea. I don't think anyone should give up on making their vision a reality on our server, but if you constantly set so many specifics for yourself that are at odds with the the reality of the server, then there's not much anyone can do to help you. And that's not saying evil or an evil settlement can't exist, you just can't expect it to poof into existence and ignore all the things that are there beforehand.
It's like trying to build a house without a hammer or powertools. You can't simply say "welp, I guess it's impossible to build this house, it's the ground's fault." I mean you can, but you look silly. So you want a big evil castle on the isle? Cool, try not to be a dick to people until you're big enough to defend yourself. Oh, taking the time to build up in relative quiet isn't your style? Cool, well, try building as loud as you want, but not in the middle of half a dozen settlements that would want to squish you. Well, that's not your style either? Okay, fine. Maybe it is impossible to build your house in this specific manner, in this specific place, while spending no more time and effort than you feel comfortable with. If that's the cop-out you're looking for, there it is. But I feel like people have given some pretty good examples of how such a goal can be accomplished, has been accomplished in the past, and might even be in the process of being accomplished now.
_________________ You think Magic is your ally... but you merely adopted the Art. He was born in it. Molded by it. Sometimes, an angel is simply a devil with better intentions.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Cracked Red Eye Orb
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 14:05 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 24 Sep 2015
|
Dead wrote: Kas wrote: Or someone who eavesdropped. That's impossible, actually. Impossible? Cool way to let dynamic things occur in roleplay, then. Boring.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 14:28 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
Quote: So you want a big evil castle on the isle? Cool, try not to be a dick to people until you're big enough to defend yourself. Oh, taking the time to build up in relative quiet isn't your style? They just wait until it's done to blow it up. This has been done. Nobody ever said anything about doing nothing to contribute or help build in their own ways, much like someone would in Kohlingen or Cordor or Tarkuul. I am just quick to detach myself from doing it as a faction. Why? Because it always blows up, and it doesn't even accomplish the real goal of this thread. I just expect that NPC's will be behind the initiative, the base plot, and the players can build from there. Heh.. if you think we can't have people from outside of amia take place in the plot, how do you explain extraneous plot devices like the Black Caravan just blowing up our temple, then almost the one replacing that? http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.p ... aravan%27d There's even an Urban Dictionary entry. If the rest of the server receives plot help, it's time evil does too. Quote: Impossible? Cool way to let dynamic things occur in roleplay, then. Boring. Yup, a major reason a lot of us are really not at all interested in Tarkuul.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
Last edited by RaveN on Fri, Nov 06 2015, 14:31 PM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kamina
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 14:30 PM |
|
|

DM
Joined: 05 Jul 2007 Location: Kent, England.
|
Faded Wings wrote: If the rest of the server receives plot help, it's time evil does too. I'm not being sarcastic as the tone of this question may be, but what would you want DMs to do aside from god-modding an area for evil to grow in?
_________________  "Operating in the border between light and darkness, shadowdancers are nimble artists of deception. They are mysterious and unknown, never completely trusted but always inducing wonder when met"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 14:37 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
|
- Monitor the RP that's being done there as best they can, through forum posts, or watching when they can - Come up with their own plot ideas to involve players that go there in whatever they want - Leave the area open towards a wider allowance of chaos but still maintain some semblance of non-abyssal law
Beyond that, it's really up to them, as it always is. If they want to establish player leadership, they can do that. If they don't, (which, IMO is healthier but unfortunately Cordor and Kohlingen and Tarkuul have ignored that plea) they can do that as well.
Ultimately it should be possible to run a faction that is based in that city but not necessarily carry any of the weight behind the city's political agenda or might.
The area is not by design supposed to belong to an evil player, but to evil on amia.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kamina
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 14:44 PM |
|
|

DM
Joined: 05 Jul 2007 Location: Kent, England.
|
Faded Wings wrote: The area is not by design supposed to belong to an evil player, but to evil on amia. I think this is something that needs to be the foundation of an active evil faction. The issue with an evil faction is either path you take with it, it comes with its cons: -Evil faction based on collective faith (E.G. Mask): While everyone has a shared goal but makes it hard to accommodate the wider spectrum of evil. -Evil faction based on various faiths: The mixture of evil roots, through religion, creed or wealth, makes the variety of the faction more attractive to newbies, however things such as goals become tougher to assign. Really, I think what seems to want to strive here is number 2. Yeah, Tarkuul is kinda the 2nd one as well, however the main focus (In particular Necromancy and forbidden knowledge) is not that attractive to some other evils (Just plain monstrous or a bad person). If the "new evil" want to do number 2, this is perhaps easiest for a DM to help with. Perhaps even an alt beginnings could help kick it off with activity. While I know the whole Black Caravan situation, I'd like to think it's no longer a case of fingerblasting an entire faction or area away /without just RP/ these days.
_________________  "Operating in the border between light and darkness, shadowdancers are nimble artists of deception. They are mysterious and unknown, never completely trusted but always inducing wonder when met"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 14:47 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
|
We'd be looking for #2 in your example, yeah. It's meant to accommodate different player's styles, ambitions, and roleplay for whatever they might want to accomplish. All while holding the most common-ground evil theme as to not make anyone feel completely excluded.
For example, it would not be devil based because demon affluenced PC's would have a major problem and vice versa. Earlier in the thread, I alluded to the concept of black knights. Coming up with a story could be fun.
It's always hard to join evil, but where Amia has done it wrong constantly, is by being overbearing with plot devices like the voice.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kamina
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 14:52 PM |
|
|

DM
Joined: 05 Jul 2007 Location: Kent, England.
|
Faded Wings wrote: We'd be looking for #2 in your example, yeah. It's meant to accommodate different player's styles, ambitions, and roleplay for whatever they might want to accomplish. Then DM help would definitely be a boon if they were to run a plot. You look at Tarkuul, the entire settlement is by definition in a constant plot (though I won't spoil what for people who don't know). Same can be said about every major settlement. Cordor's recovery from the war, Bendir Dale's lifecycle and other events. If the new faction had something to begin to form groundwork on that would be great. A couple of ideas off the top of my head is maybe an abandoned and collapsing fortress is discovered by aforementioned evil party. When they decide to squat there they soon find out it's haunted. It's through finding the source of the haunt on their journey to building their base that maybe they find something that gives them an objective. Say, a ghostly spirit who wants the heads of Kohlingen's royals, as an example. I agree with a lot of the points both sides of this 'argument' have said. Yeah, Evil /isn't/ the only side that gets things destroyed, I've seen it happen to Neutral and Good factions too. But I find what Evil lacks is DM plots to help them push forward with their goals, something I see other cities and factions get too. I'd really like to see some of the ideas Faded has put forward to happen, we need variety.
_________________  "Operating in the border between light and darkness, shadowdancers are nimble artists of deception. They are mysterious and unknown, never completely trusted but always inducing wonder when met"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 14:59 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
|
I just want to emphasize that this place is not meant to be a faction, it's meant to be a staging ground for factions, but owned by larger plot that is not directed by any one faction. That doesn't mean it can't be influenced in some ways by their actions, but I also do not want to have this city used as a plot device that would be an "invincible terrorist" either, as I do firmly believe that war has opportunity cost and depending on how the plot is shaped, they might have their reasons to do whatever they plan to do.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Silkelock
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 16:18 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Jun 2011 Location: Sweden
|
Kas wrote: Dead wrote: Kas wrote: Or someone who eavesdropped. That's impossible, actually. Impossible? Cool way to let dynamic things occur in roleplay, then. Boring. I think the contect was missed here. When he says impossible the thing he forgot to mention the level of paranoia the PCs have so most if not all sensitive information is shared in very specific ways to ensure no one gets ahold of it. Seriously, who stands on the streets of any given city and talks about plotting to take over the world? 
_________________ Life should be prolonged only when it serves the greater cause of the death of the world.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Guardian
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 17:19 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Dec 2009 Location: The Sky Above The Rain.
|
|
This "Tarkuul is invincible and impossible to spy upon" attitude is bullshit too.
I was personally a part of a quest where we were hired to assassinate Tarkuulite officier who was kidnapped and could possibly spill the beans - mind you, could "possibly". How he was kidnapped or where I do not know, but I do know Tarkuulites are not in Tarkuul and only in Tarkuul all the time. So why not approach them outside the city, outside the sanctuary it represents?
There is nothing wrong with a city that's overly paranoid about it's security. And if the players are able enough to avoid being captured or spied upon, and willing to permadie in case they fail, props to them, right?
As I said, Fade - we used to play with each other, even in Tarkuul, and you seems like a decent player. This defeatist approach does not suit you.
*I am not a part of any Tarkuulite quest atm, mind you, this experience is from the time when Glim was in charge and the playerbase was possibly slightly different too.
_________________ Mercadier - *sleeps six feet under the warm sands of Khem* Alex - Life is adventure or nothing! Eddie - Sex, drugs and rock'n... more sex. ========= Obsidian (inactive)
Last edited by Guardian on Fri, Nov 06 2015, 17:26 PM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 17:24 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
|
Until you're willing to literally level a city out of existence, and make no maps connect to any part of it anymore, I don't think you can tell me it's not invincible, when that's literally what has happened to almost every evil faction base in existence.
I'll believe it when I see it.
By calling me a defeatist, you are essentially telling me that my RP and subsequently the factions I've been in charge of, or part of have never been good enough to have taken me further than it has. Is that accurate?
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
|
|
|
|
 |
|
corypx
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 17:32 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Oct 2006
|
Faded Wings wrote: Until you're willing to literally level a city out of existence, and make no maps connect to any part of it anymore, I don't think you can tell me it's not invincible, when that's literally what has happened to almost every evil faction base in existence.
I'll believe it when I see it. You keep doing it, your comparing City to faction base but they are not the same thing.
_________________ ================-<Cory ShadowFlame>-================ Risenlord-Shifter(OMG a Non-Dragon Shifter that can hold his own in PvE) 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 17:33 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
Yup, which is why I want an evil city, not an evil faction base. Hence, this thread 
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
|
|
|
|
 |
|
corypx
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 17:41 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Oct 2006
|
Faded Wings wrote: Yup, which is why I want an evil city, not an evil faction base. Hence, this thread  And as I said, go build one but not on amia island because its not logical even if this was really FR, your trying to set up a new group in the middle of a bunch of fully supplied and supported ones who don't want your kind around there, Your trying to set up a christen church in the middle of saudi Arabia, your going to get murdered.
_________________ ================-<Cory ShadowFlame>-================ Risenlord-Shifter(OMG a Non-Dragon Shifter that can hold his own in PvE) 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Naivatkal
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 17:43 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 May 2010
|
|
Yes. A handful of people should be responsible for building an entire city. That's a terrible idea as it will take forever.
Which is why DM support is needed, if not bringing in an already existing city that can be worked on.
_________________ Whomst've'll'd'mn't I play: Salema Nefahri :: A penny for your thots Zrae'a'stra'fryn :: That which nightmares are made of Khasir :: From the East a storm is coming
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Guardian
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 17:51 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Dec 2009 Location: The Sky Above The Rain.
|
Faded Wings wrote: By calling me a defeatist, you are essentially telling me that my RP and subsequently the factions I've been in charge of, or part of have never been good enough to have taken me further than it has. Is that accurate? Oh, no. It has nothing to do with your RP. Just here, on forum, I feel like you have this "Goodies have everything, evil got nothing." attitude. Which I do not think is overly true. And yet again, I will mention the situation waaaaay back in time, when Banites used to dominate the server, how goodly players said exactly the same thing. "Evil got it all, we have nothing." Nothing's black and white. Also, I agree with Cory. Correct me if I am wrong, which I might be, but even Tarkuul is not actually on the Island, it floats somewhere above or something like that, right? So if you wish to build an overly evil place, do it out of sight and let it be known ONLY when you are absolutely sure the place is a fort no one should be able to breach, at least not without an epic, costly battle. And I think Amia B is ideal for such plan. Personally, I often spent more time on B. Places like Howness, Wiltun or Ostland are places with massive potential. Why yours should not be such a place as well?
_________________ Mercadier - *sleeps six feet under the warm sands of Khem* Alex - Life is adventure or nothing! Eddie - Sex, drugs and rock'n... more sex. ========= Obsidian (inactive)
|
|
|
|
 |
|
corypx
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 17:59 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Oct 2006
|
Naivatkal wrote: Yes. A handful of people should be responsible for building an entire city. That's a terrible idea as it will take forever.
Which is why DM support is needed, if not bringing in an already existing city that can be worked on. Never said they had to do it by themselves YOUR EVIL..... go capture some monster or bandit slaves and make them build it for you, or maybe buy some from underport like the living city did, or take a boat and sail to other evil-ish locations to find settlers. The main point was go and work on it but not on amia island because yes it really wont work because of its small area and already large groups who's lands are rubbing up against each other as is, Frozenfar and Shadowplane are the best logical locations to set up because of lack of completion as well you might be able to take something over on one of the two, in the case of the shadow plane given it kind of does a odd mirror with the prime if I recall you could in fact find a city.
_________________ ================-<Cory ShadowFlame>-================ Risenlord-Shifter(OMG a Non-Dragon Shifter that can hold his own in PvE) 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 18:04 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
What does this community even want?
I think that's where you should start. It seems like a lot of resistance or flippant consideration is being given to efforts trying to make an evil/conflict hub. Is it something that players even want? Maybe players don't want to see a thriving evil city.
I dunno. Just feels weird when people try to make it happen and are defeated, and then they receive all the blame for doing it incorrectly. Or even stupidly. Let's be honest here, no group of evil players will be successful in trying to build a city for evil. Hell, even by the nature of their building it it becomes a faction base, not a city. If its even wanted at all, it'll have to come predominantly from DM initiative.
I don't know. I just get the feeling that players on Amia want something else. What do you even want conflict on Amia to look like, and how badly do you want it? If bad enough, how willing would you be to allow your characters to fail ICly so that OOCly the source of conflict could survive and provide for the server? If in the end, players don't event want an evil hub/city as a source of conflict, why stress so hard to give it?
|
|
|
|
 |
|
The Great Equalizer
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 18:55 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Aug 2006 Location: Victoria, BC, Canada
|
|
Putting this at all on the shoulders of any players is ridiculous. You're basically missing an entire story element, something that NEEDS to exists in order for certain types of RP to exists (and last). And it isn't a matter of "Fairness" for Evil to get something just given to them because it would just be a return to balance since Evil was allowed to be Decimated on Amia to such a degree that its created this situation.
Its sort of the equivalent of a Villain's or Hero's lair in almost any given Super Hero story, how do they always have one? It doesn't really matter because all that matters is that they have one. Or seedy local Bar / Local Dinner / Mob Run Restaurant for crime novel's they are scene elements and places for characters to be in their element.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Larsaan
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 19:20 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 Jun 2010
|
|
So here's a thought I just had: why isn't evil ever trying to seduce me? I mean, it's one of the oldest themes in this genre. Demons and devils and clerics corrupting mortals by promising them the world if they'll just do this little thing, nevermind the fine print, just sign here please. The secrets of the planes will be yours, your family will never want for food, soldiers will march in your name, she will be yours forever... all at the low, low cost of your morality.
Personally, I think that is a big part of Evil's PR problem on Amia. The average character isn't joining up with Evil because the only loosely evil faction that has the resources to offer anything is Tarkuul, and Tarkuul is about as seductive as a mouldy sock. Zanshibon comes closest in terms of theme, but there's nothing there that I couldn't get anywhere else, for much less than my soul. Playing Good in the face of temptation should be hard, but since things have to be "fair" (and since Good holds all the cards anyway) there is nothing for Evil to tempt with.
_________________ Currently playing: Aven Brinyflask Safaya DalaiRiyitChsera Hile(Credits to Raua for the sprite, sauce -here-.)
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 19:47 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
Larsaan wrote: So here's a thought I just had: why isn't evil ever trying to seduce me? I mean, it's one of the oldest themes in this genre. Demons and devils and clerics corrupting mortals by promising them the world if they'll just do this little thing, nevermind the fine print, just sign here please. The secrets of the planes will be yours, your family will never want for food, soldiers will march in your name, she will be yours forever... all at the low, low cost of your morality.
Personally, I think that is a big part of Evil's PR problem on Amia. The average character isn't joining up with Evil because the only loosely evil faction that has the resources to offer anything is Tarkuul, and Tarkuul is about as seductive as a mouldy sock. Zanshibon comes closest in terms of theme, but there's nothing there that I couldn't get anywhere else, for much less than my soul. Playing Good in the face of temptation should be hard, but since things have to be "fair" (and since Good holds all the cards anyway) there is nothing for Evil to tempt with. I agree. I haven't really thought about that until you just said it.. if something like this does take off, it would be awesome to have that kind of thing! @ Hackums - I'm not qualified to answer that, but the overwhelming admission that I'm not completely crazy for this line of thought is perhaps an indication that perhaps it's time to give it a shot.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Alaria-
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:07 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 11 Jan 2013 Location: Riding the flow of the wind!
|
|
People keep referring to Tarkuul as "evil" OOC but I just don't buy it based on what I have seen. They are Neutral at best in my opinion. I don't know what goes on behind the scenes though!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Burningoutbright
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:08 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Mar 2007 Location: Where the She-Devils roam
|
|
Just wanted to say that I'm reading every post, even though I have nothing to add.
_________________ "The world takes and takes, even things that aren't offered. Finally, it gave us something back; I wish he was here to share it with me."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:09 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
Here's some more food for thought, too:
As it stands, the introduction of an evil city would almost feel out of place on Amia-- just because of the way the server is designed and how plot and character RP has progressed over the years. Creating a city from the ground up would, if we're being honest, never be allowed to happen ICly. If the city posed a direct threat to the allied forces, it would have to be destroyed before it was able to pose a threat. While it may not be preferable, it's just a logical RP viewpoint from any good-aligned character interested in keeping his home and the people inside it safe.
But what if you don't need a city? What if the kinds of 'plot protection' needed to build a steady and productive source of conflict for Amia doesn't need giant walls?
Try to think about how having a city would give you the necessary protection to be able to thrive in the first place. Then isolate those principles, and see if they can be applied to other things too. While Cordor West, for example, doesn't have a city to themselves they were able to claim relative autonomy in an area of an already existing city. They didn't have to experience the vulnerability of building, and by the time they were situated and posed a threat, they had the support of local NPC's in a way that deterred outright destruction.
Maybe, for instance, a Banite presence could overthrow a Ruathymi Jarl in Ostland and swear fealty to the Jarl of Wiltun. You'd possess autonomy over your own micro-realm while still being valuable to a more morally ambiguous source of power. Or maybe your faction resides inside Kohlingen even, as an occult group masking as Triadic personnel. And after earning enough power you're able to deflect investigations by demanding a tribunal from Church members who are already in your pockets.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:15 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
... Though maybe the Kohlingen idea shouldn't be considered beyond an example, heh! Historically, Kohlingen players prefer to avoid internal political intrigue. Which is fine-- everyone has their tastes! Which I guess, is another important point. If you want to provide conflict for people because you want to help the server thrive, make sure that you're doing it in a way that's enjoyable.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Burningoutbright
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:17 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Mar 2007 Location: Where the She-Devils roam
|
Quote: Maybe, for instance, a Banite presence could overthrow a Ruathymi Jarl in Ostland and swear fealty to the Jarl of Wiltun. You'd possess autonomy over your own micro-realm while still being valuable to a more morally ambiguous source of power. This would be okay. Would need to swear fealty to all of Ruathym, though, not just Wiltun. In fact, I recommend leaving Wiltun out of it, so you have no reason to have another Jarldom in your hair.
_________________ "The world takes and takes, even things that aren't offered. Finally, it gave us something back; I wish he was here to share it with me."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Nivo
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:18 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 09 Jan 2009 Location: East of Elsewhere, West of Sometime
|
Mr. Hackums wrote: ... Though maybe the Kohlingen idea shouldn't be considered beyond an example, heh! Historically, Kohlingen players prefer to avoid internal political intrigue. Which is fine-- everyone has their tastes! Which I guess, is another important point. If you want to provide conflict for people because you want to help the server thrive, make sure that you're doing it in a way that's enjoyable. Speaking for myself... I've been hoping for internal conflict since some upstart Mystrans came to the Holy City and started mucking up the place with magic.
_________________ Playing: Marcus Valis
|
|
|
|
 |
|
corypx
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:22 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Oct 2006
|
Mr. Hackums wrote: Maybe, for instance, a Banite presence could overthrow a Ruathymi Jarl in Ostland and swear fealty to the Jarl of Wiltun. You'd possess autonomy over your own micro-realm while still being valuable to a more morally ambiguous source of power. If they overthrow the Jarl of Ostland they would have taken over Ostland, they could maybe depose a noble house and take their holding and swear fealty to the Jarl of Ostland.
_________________ ================-<Cory ShadowFlame>-================ Risenlord-Shifter(OMG a Non-Dragon Shifter that can hold his own in PvE) 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:23 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
|
I wouldn't worry too much about that. Zhentil Keep has made it abundantly clear that they don't support the Banites on this server, and the chance of a local upstart competing with forces like Wiltun is just setting them up to be the next punching bag in this hypothetical scenario. This also once again, is talking about factions and / or player initiatives, which cannot be the sole driving factor in this idea, so, yeah... not really a problem solver.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Burningoutbright
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:30 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Mar 2007 Location: Where the She-Devils roam
|
corypx wrote: Mr. Hackums wrote: Maybe, for instance, a Banite presence could overthrow a Ruathymi Jarl in Ostland and swear fealty to the Jarl of Wiltun. You'd possess autonomy over your own micro-realm while still being valuable to a more morally ambiguous source of power. If they overthrow the Jarl of Ostland they would have taken over Ostland, they could maybe depose a noble house and take their holding and swear fealty to the Jarl of Ostland. It's possible to fragment Ostland in the wake of war, and make some pocket Jarldoms that are small. As you remember, Raorik Bathrie as well as Reginald Bathrie are both Jarls of Ostland--or were. Raorik is still in Wiltun custody, and Reginald and Regina are on the run. In Ostland, it was fragmented due to the Bathrie family attempting to share power and oppress their numerous peasants by having an oligarchy of ruling Jarls, and the Bathrie family is rumored to have committed incest to ensure the power stays in the family. Right now, after the war, Wiltun and Greater Ruathym installed the bright-eyed and novice leader, Agnar Magnus, coasting in on the coattails of being a folk-hero, due to his father being a well-liked Jarl, before he was murdered and Ostland fragmented and cut ties from the rest of Ruathym. So, if someone did play their cards right, they could snatch a small city from Agnar Magnus, hold it, declare themselves a minor Jarl of a pocket Jarldom within Ostland's greater Jarldom, and then swear fealty to Ruathym. Of course they would have Agnar Magnus and his allies potentially wanting their little city back, but then you have to deal with that as it comes.
_________________ "The world takes and takes, even things that aren't offered. Finally, it gave us something back; I wish he was here to share it with me."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Burningoutbright
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:31 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Mar 2007 Location: Where the She-Devils roam
|
Faded Wings wrote: I wouldn't worry too much about that. Zhentil Keep has made it abundantly clear that they don't support the Banites on this server, and the chance of a local upstart competing with forces like Wiltun is just setting them up to be the next punching bag in this hypothetical scenario. This also once again, is talking about factions and / or player initiatives, which cannot be the sole driving factor in this idea, so, yeah... not really a problem solver. I think it's worth explaining. I think sometimes people don't know what could be possible.
_________________ "The world takes and takes, even things that aren't offered. Finally, it gave us something back; I wish he was here to share it with me."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:32 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
Alaria- wrote: People keep referring to Tarkuul as "evil" OOC but I just don't buy it based on what I have seen. They are Neutral at best in my opinion. I don't know what goes on behind the scenes though! I would say that Tarkuul is plenty evil-- but it's also extremely pragmatic. Which, when it comes to conflict, can be somewhat problematic. Tarkuul takes an extremely careful and thorough stance of self-preservation and the exploration of forbidden knowledge. Tarkuul doesn't gamble if it can help it. Which is about what you'd expect out a city designed around occult scholars. You would be hard-pressed to see server-wide conflict coming out of Tarkuul unless it believed very strongly that it was going to win. During the Arcanum War, they were put into a position where they were forced to take chances by stepping up onto the stage. If they hadn't, they would have risked their position and become next in line for either bowing or dying. It's not that Tarkuul is ineffective and idle. It's that Tarkuul is too effective at self-preservation, to the point where it is generally unwilling to accept bringing aboard risky partnerships or sticking their neck out unnecessarily far in search of some nefarious artifact. That, in my opinion, is where the element of conflict is lost on Tarkuul. Until the city is equipped and prepared to seize the entire island of Amia in order to create a completely safe environment, stirring the pot and inviting danger to their doorstep is just outside of their ethos.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Grymia
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:32 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Dec 2004 Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada
|
|
I am actually curious as to what prompted Zhentil Keep to wash it's hands of Amia's Banites, in truth. A PM will be fine if folks don't wanna talk on the forum proper.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
TormakSaber
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:32 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 16 Dec 2004 Location: Somewhere
|
Burningoutbright wrote: Just wanted to say that I'm reading every post, even though I have nothing to add. Yups, sorry folks. I don't got much to say here (maybe surprisingly?)
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:36 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
Grymia wrote: I am actually curious as to what prompted Zhentil Keep to wash it's hands of Amia's Banites, in truth. A PM will be fine if folks don't wanna talk on the forum proper. We met with them over 10 times over 4 years, and every time the meetings were basically the same. "You guys fail at what you're doing, there's no way we will help you in any way." Some of the times we actually got told we disgraced Bane too.  Most successful evil faction in amia's history... nah, *eyeroll* just a fail.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:39 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
I think by now Faded, it should be pretty clear to DM's and players alike that any effort to create a sustainable, or at the very least longer lasting source of conflict requires active DM support and player initiative both.
The problem is that even if a DM team on its own initiative tried to create a full-sized city that has the potential to provide conflict, it would be largely impossible. It would have to be created as something new, because the current server design doesn't support one. And by the time it would create it, people would rally and destroy it. I think it's just too unrealistic to hope for.
Which is why I suggested considering smaller scale options that could provide the same principles of plot protection to groups and players. Districts of cities instead of cities themselves. Shadier parts of town, religious autonomy inside their temple, who knows.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:41 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
Or maybe Zhentil NPC's orchestrate the fall of a Jarl instead of a PC faction doing it. Is that what you're trying to say? That DM's should be working to help create this kind of environment where more wicked players and factions can stay within and be safe, rather than PC's aiming for it first?
Just asking for clarification!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:46 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
|
1) Cordor Underground - Example of an area the Banites invested 1.2 years of RP into being secretive. The location was metagamed, and destroyed within 12 hours. By the time I woke up the next day, all of the work was gone, and my entire faction was executed in after being in jail for 36 hours. Not going back to a city.
2) Zhentil Keep's NPC's have spurned what I consider some of the best RP I've ever taken place in. Personally, I'd feel almost offended if they came back now and helped people who actually do fail.
I'm thinking more along the lines of a dead god's cultists coming to Amia to harvest power and using other evil powers as allies against its threats.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:56 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
What I mean, though, is that you're asking for DM-NPC initiatives with this first and foremost, rather than PC factions trying to make it work? Whether it's Zhentil, or Cultists, or anything else.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RaveN
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:58 PM |
|
|

Administrative Developer
Joined: 08 Jun 2010
|
|
I'm asking for the DM's to help facilitate the pushing of this plot, yep. I am more than willing to come up with it, and participate in the work involved.
I just won't get started if it's a "hey, we'll help you build you this faction area..." To me, that's kind of like buying a refurbished hard drive.
_________________ a.k.a. Audrey Zinata
Last edited by RaveN on Fri, Nov 06 2015, 21:00 PM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 20:59 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
Cool, cool. Makes sense, yep.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Larsaan
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 21:22 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 Jun 2010
|
|
Personally I'd like to see some sort of planar entity start doing business in the Amia region. A rakshasa, or a dao, or an ultroloth, maybe even a coven of night hags. Something that would be interested in hiring mortal agents, but still powerful and cunning enough that it won't just get stomped by the zerg.
_________________ Currently playing: Aven Brinyflask Safaya DalaiRiyitChsera Hile(Credits to Raua for the sprite, sauce -here-.)
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Silkelock
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 21:29 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Jun 2011 Location: Sweden
|
Larsaan wrote: Personally I'd like to see some sort of planar entity start doing business in the Amia region. A rakshasa, or a dao, or an ultroloth, maybe even a coven of night hags. Something that would be interested in hiring mortal agents, but still powerful and cunning enough that it won't just get stomped by the zerg. There is a humongous floating silver orb over Cordor which the goodies just happened to forget about.
_________________ Life should be prolonged only when it serves the greater cause of the death of the world.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
NinjaClarinet
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 21:30 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Jul 2010
|
|
Don't even try to pin that one on the players, Silke, that's pretty low.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Larsaan
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 22:00 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 Jun 2010
|
Silkelock wrote: There is a humongous floating silver orb over Cordor which the goodies just happened to forget about. You know, I don't blame them. There's just about zero in-game indication that it's there, and it's not doing anything. It's about as interactive as the sun.
_________________ Currently playing: Aven Brinyflask Safaya DalaiRiyitChsera Hile(Credits to Raua for the sprite, sauce -here-.)
|
|
|
|
 |
|
SamTheGiantSlayer
|
Posted: Fri, Nov 06 2015, 22:00 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 31 Mar 2014
|
|
I'll have to agree that we all know that plot did not falter entirely at the hand of players. I think it's important to emphasize that these issues go both ways. We are all players, DM or not. We all get burnt out. We all let things slips between the cracks.
_________________ Thats the way it crumbles ... cookie-wise!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Richard_Edmund
|
Posted: Sat, Nov 07 2015, 0:31 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 23 Sep 2012 Location: Western Australia (+8 GMT)
|
|
I think we saw how well Ostland fared when evil tried to work itself there. Let's stray from recommending that it is in any way a good idea to invite that type of thing again to the region that is troubled enough as it is. Otherwise it'll be another two or more years of clusterfuck.
_________________ Elwyn Sabel - Laura Jarshall - Mordoc Ebonhand
Discord: Bhaalorian#5715
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Comatose
|
Posted: Sun, Nov 08 2015, 4:07 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 Aug 2014
|
|
Here are a few things off the top of my head that I wouldn't mind seeing in a so called "evil" city.
- Poverty - High crime rate - Lower education - Declining property values - Lack of law enforcement - High taxes - Abandoned businesses/ buildings
|
|
|
|
 |
|
The1Kobra
|
Posted: Sun, Nov 08 2015, 15:49 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 11 Oct 2009
|
|
Are successful villains/evil PCs possible on Amia? I'd certainly think so, as with the prior mentioned examples of Tarkuul and Cordor West's Gentlemen's Club. But what would you qualify as 'successful'? I don't think the definition will be the same for two people. For example, one might consider their evil PC successful if they create a lot of mayhem and madness, but were caught and executed in the end, their success was that it created fun roleplay and they did get some notoriety out of it. Another would not consider it successful because they got caught and executed in the end. Your mileage may vary.
Now for evil settlements, I'd certainly say we have settlements that are evil aligned, and that evil PCs can fit in them. But there's a catch to this, since evil is a rather wide bucket, and you can't just put them all in one place. Pragmatic evil characters won't get along with ax crazy evil characters, demon and devil aligned evil characters, ax crazy characters with other ax crazy characters, it goes on. It's much harder to get evil characters to cooperate than it is with other alignments, and evil cities have been prone to self destruction and infighting in the past. Demons despite being infinitely (literally) more powerful than everyone else in the cosmos can't conquer the multiverse because they're handicapped by their own behavior. PCs don't have the luxury of that power disparity.
But getting back to settlements, each settlement has it's own interests and desires. (Assuming they're cohesive entities) and also tend to be more on the pragmatic side, because it's hard to make a city run on some flavor of evil alone, they still need to make sure the trains come in on time. Each city has a theme to it, a kind of evil that clicks best with it, and can make it work best.
Cordor West is a more chaotic mafioso themed place. Crime, corruption, illicit substances, black markets, under a thin veneer of legitimacy. The idol of Valkur is well placed, despite being CG, he represents the self made man, relying on the self in the face of adversity, which meshes well with the old commonwealth's ideology, and of casting down the nobility who represent status by birth rather than deed. The idol of Illmater is a bit more jarring, since they don't like Triadists due to Kohlingen's invasion, and poverty is rather low thanks to the efforts of the Gentlemen's club, though of course the district's poor do go there for succor. Either way, there will be some good even in corrupt human settlements, it's hard to make it even work if it's all doom and gloom.
Chillywyck is remote, and largely caters to Aurilites. Remote and kind of a narrow focus, but I think the furies could base there. (What happened to the horseman base there, by the way?)
Zanshibon: Perfect place for CE and especially demon inclined factions, though the implementation of the travel system makes the area even more remote. Of course, it's on the abyss and to be expected, but it could be used for a faction base, as long as they don't anger Paush. Lawful evils will likely face resistance here.
L'Obsul: Caters exclusively to underdarkers, and in the past there haven't been enough non-drow underdarkers, much less cohesive ones, to make it work. Most kobolds work with surfacers, and drow have tended to exclude and abuse their non-drow neighbors, making cooperation non-existant. It might be able to serve as an under-cordor if it were to relax the surfacer restrictions, though, and cater to evil humans, half-orcs, and other outcasts, etc.
Nec'perya: Exclusive to drow. Traditionalist Lolthite drow at that.
I was admittedly sad to see Underport go, it provided a nice undertrading, shady place for evils to plot and sell off captive PCs for ransoms. Heck, one of my PCs managed to extort 500,000 gold and 50 greater mythals in one night from this place. And was later killed by an evil PC who's plans were disrupted by those of my PC. I do think that a replacement settlement to fill the niche would be nice.
And, Tarkuul.
Tarkuul is by far the largest and most powerful of the evil settlements (perhaps discarding Zanshibon, but most powerful on the plane). Tarkuul is powerful enough that they could glass Cordor with all the effort of a casual shrug, and do the same to Wharftown, Guldorand, almost any settlement on the isle. Yet despite being leagues of magnitude stronger than the rest, I oft hear gripes about how it's unsuitable for evil PCs, despite allowing anyone that doesn't directly cause problems for it. Tarkuul is on the extreme end of the pragmatic end of villainy, lawful more than chaotic. They don't want to be entangled in problems that don't benefit them (so taking captives is out). But it's a near impenetrable fortress to plot and scheme from, and as long as they don't anger the host, it should all be alright. But I don't think any of the settlements want hellball in the streets craziness. PCs can get a rental home in places and stay loose from the politics if they want to. The city itself isn't aggressive though, it doesn't gain anything out of it, and destroying the other powers would be more like stomping on ants, to it.
I struggle to come up with how a 'pure evil catch all' city can work with realistic sociodynamics. Say you have a place which allows all evil and bars all good, but how can you make that work? Even assuming they could manage to keep out anyone good, and the city bans altruism, charity, etc, how would they handle the ax crazy evils who throw hellballs in the street? How do they handle evils that work directly against them or want to take it over? The city would have to have some self interest and enforcement to not completely collapse into infighting, but then if they start throwing out such elements, then it's back to the situation with Tarkuul, isn't it? That or they have a literally invincible guardian that can prevent PCs from reducing the city to rubble from within, but people are generally against that to my perceptions. Add to this they need to feed everyone, provide a stable economy, etc, it's not easy to run a place solely on some flavor of evil.
But I do think something can be improved here, especially because interacting with the settlements requires a lot of DM attention and commitment. Similarly, even villages have had their defenses buffed very hard, because of past instances where places that didn't have extremely good guards got razed to the ground by evil PCs. (Kampo's many times, Guldorand). So what can be fixed here?
Personally, a thought of mine was to have the smaller settlements/villages be 'conquerable' as it were, that way it would give PCs things to fight over. I'd leave the large cities untouched with this for now, since they're large places with a lot of power and resources, and their own interests. A village would be less apt to keep factions out, and also help keep PCs contesting over it. Ones that come to mind are: Wharftown, Cordor West, Endir's Point, and Guldorand. Now naturally they'd all have their own tastes and preferences, but it would be more mutable to PC desires. If it could be an automated system, even better. I'm not sure how it would be implemented, but I think it could be done. Mind, this would only really work if the conquering PCs don't just decide to up and raze the place. If this happened, the remaining ones would either be reduced to piles of rubble rather quickly as has happened in the past, or they would have to fort up to the point that the cities are, thus back to square one.
Still, I think that's one of the expectations one should have if making a more ax crazy evil PC, they're naturally going to have trouble getting friends and allies and won't have such resources and will have to rely more on themselves. It's hard to make allies with people who are just as likely to stab you in the back as they are to help with any villainous plans. And if they aren't willing to reign in the ax craziness to cooperate with others for their plans, then they naturally will have to deal with the consequences of that.
I do think there could be more aggression and conquering/subjugation in extant settlements, good PCs would want to liberate and help them, evil PCs conquer and have a base, etc, might help with giving villain PCs more to do if they're dissatisfied working with extant evil cities. Granted, what we likely don't want is the insanity that's happened in the past when people would throw hellballs in the streets of Cordor on a daily basis.
_________________ I play: 
|
|
|
|
 |
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 22 guests |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum
|
|