AMIA ARCHIVE • View topic

I love this functionAs some of you may have noticed, I've been updating Llunet Elutil's journal quite a lot since creation.

I'm well aware of the minor misspellings I do here and there (which I try to fix when I notice).
But otherwise, I would love some feedback on the content, style, format and anything else in it.

If you have some neat tips or tricks when it comes to forum formatting I'd love to know!
Do it here or if you'd prefer; a PM.

Thank you beforehand!

Generally, I find your post to be aesthetically pleasing with clear font, pretty formatting and supporting pictures.
Spelling/grammatical mistakes do not bother me much as I undoubtedly make them by the dozen. I also approve of the average topic length, not overly long, and I quite like the content.

There is one time however you made me cringe. (And this is just my personal experience, I'm just stating it since you asked for feedback) There is one time you posted in the libraries topic to ask the author of an unfinished work if such would be completed. My personal issue with that topic is threefold. 1. It would imply that the comment has been placed in all the copies of the book. (In this case however it's not so much a restriction as it is only published in one library as per the topic title) 2. It's like people writing in books. Pet peeve of mine as books are holy. 3. It would personally annoy me as the topic creator since my OCB would kick up every time I look at the topic to flare about the fact that the format will not be maintained through it all.

But as said, a very personal remark/experience. Please keep up the posts as I appreciate your presence as a player enriching our little world of mental fancies.

Dergaii wrote:

Generally, I find your post to be aesthetically pleasing with clear font, pretty formatting and supporting pictures.
Spelling/grammatical mistakes do not bother me much as I undoubtedly make them by the dozen. I also approve of the average topic length, not overly long, and I quite like the content.

There is one time however you made me cringe. (And this is just my personal experience, I'm just stating it since you asked for feedback) There is one time you posted in the libraries topic to ask the author of an unfinished work if such would be completed. My personal issue with that topic is threefold. 1. It would imply that the comment has been placed in all the copies of the book. (In this case however it's not so much a restriction as it is only published in one library as per the topic title) 2. It's like people writing in books. Pet peeve of mine as books are holy. 3. It would personally annoy me as the topic creator since my OCB would kick up every time I look at the topic to flare about the fact that the format will not be maintained through it all.

But as said, a very personal remark/experience. Please keep up the posts as I appreciate your presence as a player enriching our little world of mental fancies.

Thank you for the feedback on the journal!
As for the book, indeed, I realized it later that I probably should have just sent a PM to the person instead.
Hopefully, a moderator can delete what I posted, haha!

Feedback/suggestions appreciated!

Who is online